Bishop Robert Duncan of Pittsburgh has successfully filed for incorporation with the state of Pennsylvania to create a new corporation titled the Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh. A long-time critic of Bishop Robert Duncan claims the action is intended to make legal challenges to diocesan ownership of property more difficult in the event that delegates to the annual convention vote to disaffiliate from The Episcopal Church in October.
 
Writing in his parish newsletter, the Rev. Harold Lewis, rector of Calvary Church, Pittsburgh, said “we believe the action was taken because [Bishop Duncan] knows fully well that, as we have long contended, he is not entitled to take the assets belonging to the Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh to the Province of the Southern Cone. For this reason it would appear that he has formed a corporation under the name of the Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh, in the hope that that new entity can serve as the repository of diocesan assets.”
 

Fr. Lewis, Calvary’s senior warden, and the parish sued Bishop Duncan and the diocese in 2003 after a special convention adopted a resolution that declared in part that property in the name of individual parishes belonged to the local congregation. Calvary and the diocese settled without a trial. The parties agreed that the existing diocesan leadership was competent to administer the assets of the diocese and that they would continue to be administered in accord with past practice.

Wicks Stephens, chancellor of the Anglican Communion Network and a member of the Pittsburgh standing committee, denied that the filing was intended to transfer assets to the Southern Cone or anywhere else.

 “There is no intention to affect a transfer of property,” Mr. Stephens said. “The incorporation was designed to protect the diocese’s continued use of its name. Fr. Lewis continues to try to establish that diocesan property will be transferred to some other province. No matter how often Fr. Lewis makes that claim, it will not come true. In the event of realignment with the Southern Cone, there will be no property exchange involved. The proposed realignment would be of a temporary and emergency nature only.”

 
We invite your response to this article through a Letter to the Editor. Email your letter to tlc@livingchurch.org. Please include your name, city and state.
 
To find more news, feature articles, and commentary about the Episcopal Church and the Anglican Communion not available online, read The Living Church magazine each week. Click here to start your subscription.