The church should get out of the marriage business, said the Rt. Rev. Barbara Harris during Integrity USA’s General Convention Holy Eucharist on Friday night.
Bishop Harris endorsed the belief—widespread among Episcopal clergy—that couples should turn to the state for civil marriage ceremonies and to the church for subsequent ceremonies of blessing.
“Marriage is a civil contract to which the church, in the name of God, adds a blessing,” she said.
Taking a shot at patriarchy, the bishop joked that same-sex marriage is a longstanding pattern: “Historically, marriage was a contract between a father and a groom.”
Harris referred briefly to a reading from Acts about St. Peter hearing God’s call to welcome Gentiles into the church. Otherwise, her sermon was a collection of barbs—most aimed at conservatives, but with a few challenging her fellow progressives.
— “Unfortunately, many people who need to be reminded of these truths are not here,” she said, referring to the lesson from Acts.
— “Some glibly speak of our diversity. … I am reminded that there was diversity at the Tower of Babel.”
— Resolution B033 was “not just a grudging response to the Windsor Report, but a ticket … to attend the Lambeth Conference and to make false peace.”
— The Archbishop of Canterbury’s message to General Convention, as condensed by Bishop Harris: “Don’t make another unilateral move on the Communion chess board.”
— “If you don’t want GLBT folks as bishops, don’t ordain them as transitional deacons.”
— “Better yet, don’t baptize them in the first place.”
— “Don’t initiate someone and then act like they’re half-ass baptized.”
The Rt. Rev. Gene Robinson, bishop of New Hampshire, presided at the Eucharist. Combined choirs from All Saints Episcopal Church, Pasadena, led a standing-room-only congregation of several hundred in rousing hymns and spirituals.
The planners of Integrity’s Eucharist thoroughly transformed the Pacific Ballroom in the Hilton Hotel into a place of lively worship.
Three large and colorful parasols marked a gospel station, and a large bronze baptismal font topped a brightly draped altar. A procession before the Gospel reading marched through every aisle between the movable seats, filling the room with incense. Bishop Robinson scattered baptismal water generously during the gospel procession.
After Bishop Harris offered her teaching—the program did not call it a sermon—Bishop Robinson and the Rev. Thomas Wilson of All Souls Church in Point Loma led a visually stunning Prayers for the Ministry of All the Baptized.
The program invited members of the congregation to step toward the altar if they fit in any of several categories:
— “All those who have led the fight against injustice toward lesbian and gay people, and those who have proclaimed the good news of God’s liberation to the lesbian and gay community.”
— All families (married, covenanted, committed blessed) and children.”
— All clergy.
As people crowded around the altar to the point of overflowing, most had their arms around each other. Bishop Robinson invited everyone to touch a neighbor as he prayed: “May the Spirit be the storm that shakes the foundations, the leap of new fire, which turns oppression to ash, and may her wildness infuse us with holy desire. This we ask through Jesus Christ our Lord.”
Douglas LeBlanc reporting from General Convention in Anaheim
A one-year subscription to The LivingChurch Online also gives you convenient access to more than a year of archived issues, all for just $25! Click here to start your subscription to the TLC Online Edition today!


4 Comments
Marriage is a God ordained relationship -- God created Man, then he created his help-mate, Woman. Bible believing Christians & Jews agree on that.
I don't see why we Americans, that live in the most advanced and most free nation in the world (thanks to early founders who unashamedly embraced their Bibles) have to now throw out Marriage just to appease the miniscule homosexual community.
I'm perplexed at the vehemence that homosexuals argue for their non-Christian demands in a Christian Church setting. Instead of getting the Church out of 'Marriage' -- why don't the homosexuals simply partake in their state sanctioned civil unions, and leave the 'Church' to Marriage?
If they get 'their way' Marriage will lose its instrinsic meaning.
It's ignorant to think that there wont be continued dire consequences in society as the activists destroy the last remnants.
When Gene Robinson prays for the ..."Wildness of the Holy Spirit to infuse us with 'Her' holy desire." That just sounds wrong to me. I don't think the Holy Spirit has ever been described as wild', and I know the Holy Spirit has never been called 'Her'.
The Holy Spirit, is powerful in Believers' lives, but it brings self-control not 'holy desire'. Robinson seems to use words he reads in the Bible, and then reconfigures them to suit his own holy? desires.
Actually, the program invited members of the congregation to step toward the altar if they fit in any of the several categories:
-- "...all those lay members of the baptized community whom the Spirit has summoned to lead God's holy people, to serve as leaders in public life and those who have challenged authority by proclaiming the justice of God's reign in the prophetic power of the Spirit, especially those who speak through quiet steadfast service"
-- All families (married, covenanted, committed blessed) and children."
— "all those whom the Spirit has called to shepherd and serve the Holy Baptized people of God in ordained ministry, for all deacons, priests and bishops, who have claimed their identity as lesbian and gay people in the face of hostility, unemployment and oppression. And on this day we lift up those priests, who by the gift of their sexuality, are barred from the episcopate."
Thanks for this, Doug! Glad you were there!
Susan Russell
Not all are called to "Holy Orders,"
Are we going to say "there are no borders?
No standards? No faith? Just anything goes?"
Then watch TEC celebrate its final death throes.